by mitch on Wed Jun 17, 2009 5:46 am
Welcome, Bran, to the forum. I think that it is great of you to share your struggles. I have also struggled for years to control this. I sympathize in a way with Brad's views because I think if one has such a view of masturbation as "solo sex, just with a hand instead of a vagina" there is nothing wrong with it and then there is no guilt. I think there is a real push today to recognize masturbation as healthy because virtually everyone does it, and most people seem to turn out okay. But, I think Brad is ignoring the more important issue of how we view sexuality and relationships, as well as the way that this addiction (combined with pornography, more often than not) can cause such addictive behaviors. I agree that the guilt is often self-destructive, but it does not cause the addictive behaviors. And I don't think that it is honoring to women to equate solo sex with sexual intercourse. Physically, there are similiarities of course, but it just seems wrong to me. I certainly would never try to make people feel guilt for masturbating, an activity I have done for 25 years. But, I think if someone is trying to get more self-control over actions that they consider to be harmful, it is good to encourage them, not to tell them they should just continue with this and embrace it. In the gospels, Jesus talks about the narrow way, about taking up our cross and following him. Though I can't say what this means for everyone, or even to tell the truth, for myself, I don't think that embracing masturbation and pornography is the answer. It is the path of least resistance for sure, and for some people it does not seem addictive or destructive, but for many of us it is. Bran, don't give up. Also, don't be discouraged or let guilt cause you to doubt that you are a young man who can give yourself to a woman who will fully satisfy your desires and will love you for who you are.